Advanced Search
Advanced Search

The Sinister Effects Of SESTA

About the author: Allison Leigh is a pornographer, producer, polyamorist, and professional kinkster. When sexuality is business, business is fun! 

If you’re at all concerned about US politics or internet freedoms, you’re likely to be aware of SESTA-FOSTA. The controversial sex trafficking bill was passed by the Senate with a startling 97–2 roll call vote on March 21st, and signed into law on April 11th. SESTA-FOSTA is aimed at curbing human trafficking by removing CDA Section 230 harbors for websites that host potential sex traffickers, but its effects have already reached far further. Sex workers and internet freedom advocates are outspokenly protesting the bill, saying that it not only censors online speech, but puts consensual sex workers in real danger. 

Removing the protections of the Communications Decency Act means that websites are held legally culpable for activity they host - which upon initial reading, might sound like a good thing. However, the implications are more far-reaching than the stated intent of the bill, essentially removing the ability for sex workers to screen clientele, post advertising, and discuss their work, including sharing resources like “bad date lists” and mental health support. 

The moment SESTA-FOSTA left the US Senate, its dramatic reach began to emerge. Under the new laws, any discussion of sex work might now be considered discussion of sexual trafficking - and websites that host those conversations are shutting down left and right to avoid prosecution. Even before it was signed into law, many sites shuttered these conversations. Within 24 hours, Reddit closed their “escorts,” “male escorts,” “hookers,” and “sugar daddy” forums. Craigslist removed their personals section entirely - a move that is statistically significant, as the website’s presence has been proven to increase the safety of sex workers, reducing related homicides by 17 percent.

As the wave of changes continues, dozens of sites have closed entirely, and plenty of mainstream providers have reinforced the anti-sexuality sentiment in their terms of service, and stepped up their enforcement. Sex workers on Twitter have reported having their Google Drives wiped of content. Private Skype calls and Instagram DM’s are now subject to censorship of sexual content, and Instagram has been closing accounts. Porn sites are shuttering their comments sections and membership profiles to avoid potential violations. 

Until the government begins to enforce these laws and we can learn more about how they will be applied, their effects are unknown and potentially vast, as basically any form of communication can be used to “promote or facilitate” sex trafficking. The practical effect is that sexual speech on the internet is now subject to scrutiny, or being prevented altogether by cautious websites wishing to avoid a lawsuit. 

Despite its impact on the lives of consensual sex workers, and the erosion of online free speech, SESTA-FOSTA actually does little to accomplish its goal of fighting human trafficking. Recently closed website BackPage, charged with facilitating prostitution and money laundering, was a commonly used medium for finding traffickers and trafficking victims; its loss will take their business further underground and make trafficking harder to fight, putting more people in danger. This is what sex workers are most worried about - that they are being driven further into the dark, away from the resources that protect them.

Sex workers are responding to the new laws by fleeing social media in droves. Some have started their own networking websites based in other countries, in the hope of avoiding law enforcement and continuing to screen their clientele safely; sites like “Switter” - sex worker twitter - are cropping up across the web, though there are no protections offered by such changes. Organizations like Sex Workers Outreach Project, Free Speech Coalition, and the Adult Performer Advocacy Committee are offering support, and Twitter accounts like @pornlaw, run by lawyer Michael Fattorosi, are reaching out with advice and workshops on moving forward safely under the new restrictions.

At first read, SESTA-FOSTA sounds like an altruistic bill aimed at catching the bad guys and holding websites liable instead of allowing them to evade what seems like their responsibility. It was endorsed by celebrities who told sob stories about how these websites were havens for traffickers, and how shutting them down would save lives. In reality, it is a nightmarishly nonspecific web of potential implications for free speech, sexuality, and the safety of consensual sex workers and trafficking victims alike. We can only hope that the inevitable legal battle forces the Supreme Court to turn their eyes toward the subject and overturn these erroneous decisions as unconstitutional under the Second Amendment. 

This post first appeared on MyErotica.com

REFERENCES:

Cole, Samantha. “Trump Just Signed SESTA/FOSTA, a Law Sex Workers Say Will Literally Kill Them.” Motherboard, Vice.com, 11 Apr. 2018, motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/qvxeyq/trump-signed-fosta-sesta-into-law-sex-work

De Angelo, Gregory J. Craigslist’s Effect on Violence Against Women. gregoryjdeangelo.com/workingpapers/Craigslist5.0.pdf

Fattorosi, Michael. “How Does FOSTA Impact Camming, Dating, Porn & Tube Sites…” AdultBizLaw.com, AdultBizLaw.com, 15 Apr. 2018, adultbizlaw.com/2018/04/15/how-does-fosta-impact-camming-dating-porn-tube-sites/amp/

French, Michael. “Backpage.com Prosecutors Reveal New Details on Site Shutdown Case.” AVN, 17 Apr. 2018, avn.com/business/articles/legal/backpagecom-prosecutors-reveal-new-details-on-site-shutdown-case-772645.html

“Roll Call Vote on Passage of HR 1865 SESTA/FOSTA / Last Vote of the Day | Senate Democratic Leadership.” The Floor, Senate Democrats , 21 Mar. 2018, www.democrats.senate.gov/2018/03/21/roll-call-vote-on-passage-of-hr-1865-last-vote-of-the-day

 

Members Comments (2)

S

Spiritof42 1 month agoLifetime member

The SESTA/FOSTA law seems to follow a common pattern. It expands government power over innocents while accomplishing nothing towards reducing predators. Drug laws are a good example.

J

Johannes BLT 4 months agoLifetime member


Wow, lots of info to think about here; was not aware of all this. After careful reading (another excellent essay Allison Leigh), I can see reasons to be in favor of this new law, but I hate to see the good guys lose their rights, safeguards and their lifestyle/business(?). I hate it when that happens.

How does this population, "sexual workers", have any kind of political action advocate; I mean, seriously, how do you write to your senator or congressperson about something like this?

Concerning the Met Art family, I know this will probably affect the cam girls eventually, but what about the rest?

Get Free Content

Follow MetArt

Latest Comments

    P

    PeteLabia 26 minutes ago

    Good set - in 82 it's a shame Alise is pulling her bum open rather than her pussy - but still not complaining too much.

    on Cotio
    l

    loveu69 31 minutes ago

    We have been spoiled today with some delicious ass views from new and established models, Alise-moreno is no exception and her anus is delicious and so inviting to kiss, lick and more. And as dear beetle extols the magnificence of her dark nipples,(and much more too) I will praise her fleshy pink and deep brown anal valley and echo Alise -moreno is perfect for many of us. 8)

    on Cotio
    S

    Sniksoh 43 minutes ago

    Sweet Sherie Oh so soft on the pallet, soft and relaxed debut, once again a beauty from the Russian Federation :)

    on Presenting Sherie
    J

    JANN 47 minutes ago

    perfect !!!!more !!!

    on Hergie
    l

    loveu69 48 minutes ago

    Lisa's mildly open pussy certainly got my pulse going along with having her knickers half way down and stretched across her thighs FDAU, something I always find very erotic and sexy when a woman hasn't fully committed to taking them off. 8)

    on Dochet
    b

    beetle 52 minutes ago

    I do not know, if we can and should compare the photos and performances of Lisa Dawn and Slava. Nevertheless, I want to briefly describe my opinion.
    Slava is indescribably beautiful and rightly on one of the top 10 models of MetArt.
    Lisa is also beautiful, but perhaps not quite compared to the beauty and purity of Slava.
    Nevertheless, I like the photos and the performances of Lisa more. She is sexually much more aggressive, present and seductive than Slava, who acts rather reserved. I do not think, that's just the photographer, it's up to the actresses too.
    I see that not only the perfect beauty of the models, but also and above all the display of your own naked body - at least for me - is incredibly important. And there Lisa has the nose ahead.

    on Dochet
    N

    Nightingale 55 minutes ago

    A lovely 😊,lovely day on MetArt with both Model and Photographer giving it their best,in all 4 shoots.But Slava is my favourite because she has a wonderful smile and attitude and Tora has let her shine.
    P.S. We have not seen a two girl shoot for a long ,long time have they been banned?

    on Vanella
    b

    beetle 1 hour ago

    Alise Moreno is one of those girls, who have never disappointed me. Each of her performances is worth seeing and erotically appealing. Of course, Alise is simply sexually attractive and seductive. But these are other girls too. And yet she is different. She exudes an inner peace and strength, that impresses me every time.
    Today, Alise once again shows everything, she has to offer. Every taste of us is served by her and by Flora. Whether it's total images, or close-ups of her breasts, pussy, anus or feet. As I said, every preference of us is served.
    My favorite photos are those of Alises breasts - are they really medium size or not rather small? She has magnificant almost black nipples. Unique in this beauty and quality.
    And of course the close-ups of Alise's shapely feet, which I want kiss immediately.
    Alise Moreno is perfect.

    on Cotio
    l

    loveu69 1 hour ago

    Wow what a delightful young woman, great debut. That mane of hair is fabulous all the way down to her butt. Speaking of which those FDAU views have me hitting the favorite button, if a new face on MA, or perhaps I should say a new bottom has her showing this level of confidence putting her anus my way, then thats perfect. I also love the dark shadow and wisps of hair around her bits that are so sexy. Welcome to MA, I'm looking forward to your next outing. 8)

    on Presenting Sherie
    B

    Barnie 2 hours agoLifetime member

    Absolutely honey from the very beginning gorgeous

    on Vennia